I mean this is what Mamdani says his administration would build in NYC… but I’m kinda skeptical on how that’s supposed to stop some store from just sending like few employees/family members to go in one by one yo buy lots of their stock at the 30% discount and then resell it at standard prices. 🤔
(Not trying to shade Mamdani but I have skepticism of politician promises)
A lot of good points here, but one I haven’t seen is: scarcity.
Scalping works on items that are scarce. Tickets to events are finite. Supply is finite, so prices are largely driven by demand. Scalping is arguably as much of an issue of suppliers under-pricing these things as anything else. If AMD had set the retail price of the 9070XT at $1,000 USD instead of $600 then scalpers would not have been able to profit.
Groceries in America are not, broadly speaking, scarce. The issues we face are of distribution. Neighborhoods where corporate grocery chains are not satisfied with the profit margins they can extract, so they just choose not to do business there. Tons of perfectly fine food gets tossed every day because it cannot be distributed properly.
If someone goes to one of these city-owned grocery stores and buys up all the bananas to try to re-sell them at higher prices, what happens? The grocery store will order more bananas and have them within a few days, probably while the original ones are still green. Some shoppers might buy the market-rate bananas, some might just go without, some might buy apples or oranges instead.
Some groceries can be scarce. Organic red plantains might have different results than your standard Cavendish in this scenario. But these stores are likely not going to be carrying those sorts of rare grocery items anyways.
You’re proposing to do market arbitrage on bananas and sacks of rice. More power to you. But the existence of the store anyone can go to sets a baseline other retailers have to respond to. If the best they can do is buy from the coop to sell from their storefront, they’re already fucked.
Most retail relies on a markup of 2x or higher to make money, including decisions requiring optimizing logistics from suppliers.
What you’re talking about is only a 1.3x markup to buy from Mamdani’s grocery stores and the logistics of getting those goods into other stores is going to be far higher than major supermarket chains.
Scalping doesn’t work well with perishable goods. There’s also not a lot of room for margin, even if you can manage to sell at 100% of normal prices it’s maybe $1 of profit per item. A few bunches of bananas going bad before you sell them could eliminate a significant amount of that profit. There’s very little chance you net anywhere near minimum wage on the time spent scalping groceries.
I… don’t think scalpers are the biggest problem tbh. They have to first make sure they don’t just massively hemorrhage money from the get-go
The problem is that grocery chains already run on razor-thin margins. So if a government want to run something that is comparable or even cheaper than private grocery stores, they have to 1) make their operations extremely efficient, and on top of it 2) they have to heavily subsidize it somehow. And if subsidies are part of the equation… governmental subsidies have to come from somewhere. Putting $100 towards grocery stores could mean putting $100 less towards say homeless shelters or unemployment benefits or sth, even if the latter is more effective at helping the poor than the former
However… I did see some online discussion saying that maybe they want to operate in “food deserts” without real supermarkets, and the 30% discount may be against convenience stores. Their document seem to hint at the keyword “access to grocery stores” too. If that’s the case it should be doable, apparently Atlanta pulled off such a deal after their local Walgreens closed (it’s a public-private partnership though, not 100% public). And if that’s the case, massive subsidies would be justified as you’d be helping residents with otherwise no fresh produce access
The scalper issue also happens with Goodwill, no? Methinks it’s more of a logistics issue that only matters once they actually start the thing…
According to the 2025 financial report of Ahold Delhaize, a parent company who owns a whole bunch of grocery stores in the US and Europe (like Giant, Food Lion), the company increased profits from 1.8billion in 2024 to 2.3billion in 2025. That does not sound like razor thin margins to me. Source: Ahold Delhaize financial report
That’s because you aren’t including any context.
The $2.3 billion in 2025 net income was off net sales of $92.4 billion, so approximately 2.5%. 2024 net income was $1.8B from $89.4B net sales, about 2%.
That’s quite a thin margin, though they increased it by 25% in one year, and in line with the grocer average of 1-3%. Compare this to your average American mechanic at about 6.5%, florists at 10%, Nvidia, recently with an astounding 56.39%, or Whole Foods at about 35%.
Their point is that even if you were to remove the entirety of the profit margin, this amounts to a low percentage decrease in prices, in this retailer’s case about 2.5% on average.
Right, but the city-owned grocery stores don’t even need to make that 2.5%. In theory, they should operate as a non-profit at best.
If you take the view that food is a public good and lack thereof has downstream costs, I suspect that selling food at a loss might reduce education costs (since hungry kids probably need more remedial help). If the city-owned grocery stores are more willing to let some shoplifting slide, it probably reduces both insurance costs (that a regular grocery store would need to pay) and policing costs (that a regular grocery store would get “for free”, but the city would otherwise be paying for). Then there’s the whole “desperate people turn to crime” angle that might further reduce the policing budget if food is more affordable.
How much of this is true? I don’t know. I don’t work on the NYC budget. I’m just tired of people evaluating public services like businesses, ignoring how interconnected public services are and how much businesses get “for free” from public services.
Profit margins under 5% are considered pretty low. Google has like a 50% profit margin.
Last I read, they were only opening 5, one in each borough. Not impactful any way you look at it.
But yes, margins are paper thin and I wish people understood this about some businesses. I want higher wages across the board, but in some cases it’s not as simple as taking the CEO’s pay, which is in almost all cases a microscopic percent of profit.
Mamdani is opening a whopping 5 stores, one in each borough. That amounts to zero impact across 8,500,000 souls. And keep in mind, driving in NYC is a PITA, especially Manhattan. Among many other reasons, it’s not worth the time and gas to try and scalp from these stores.
Do you really think if it’s successful they open more? This is a pilot program.
“scalpers” don’t exist. The only people that will be buying stuff to resell are bodegas, but they already do that with Costco wholesale and such.
So still a net benefit.
Two things, first the store doesn’t need to generate profits like a normal store. They might not make as much as other stores, but 30% discount doesn’t necessarily mean operating at a loss.
So if other stores are doing that, it will just help the state-run store. They might occasionally sell out of stuff, but they can order more and limit individual purchase quantities.
Grocery stores have a margin averaging around 1.6% to 2.1%. If you give a 30% discount on >7% of the products sold, it is impossible to break even. That is before you consider government inefficiencies or the giant overhead of starting a store chain.
Blaming grocery stores for grocery prices is such a waste of time any money. The branded food manufacturers (e.g Nestle) and meatpackers (e.g. Tyson) raked in record profits during and following COVID during during the highest food inflation.
These grocery stores will be government subsidized food. I would suggest people look up which countries subsidize food and gas for the public, they are not generally great countries.
There’s no fucking way that’s true.
The park slope coop was like 11% markup, and it was one of the best places to buy things in all NYC because of how cheap it was.
It’s true because it is actual numbers from actual financial statements from actual accountants that go to actual jail if they commit fraud (probably not jail TBH). It is not based on feels like most of these anecdotes. 11% markup on what? The wholesale price is completely different depending on if you are a Coop, Walmart, Costco, ect.
Grocery stores make very little money, but get 100% of the blame apparently.
Removed by mod
Cute.
30 percent discount absolutely means operating at a loss unless run by volunteers, no rent, and free utilities.
They won’t pay rent. Also no shareholders to steal the profits
Eminent domain means no rent. The government pays “fair market value” for a property (as assessed by the government), and that’s a fixed cost.
So they ‘save’ money by laying out millions of dollars up front in capital costs? Where does that come from? There is no efficiencies here.
It’s a subsidized grocery store, which is fine, as long as that’s clear. Everyone deserves food. This is not a coat effective way to accomplish that. But the end goal is admirable.
That’s how grocery stores make such obscene profits where I live. They have a company that owns all their real estate, and they pay rent to themselves. They just set the rent to whatever they need it to be to claim their margins on the actual grocerceries are razor thin. Supermarkets make their profits from their radical vertical integration, not from the measly profit margin they apply at retail.
Eh… yeah you are right, but I just mean occupancy cost doesn’t wash to zero if you buy the building.
But yeah some(a lot… all?) large grocers position themselves as just skimping by when they are making additional revenue through the side door.
And then… the vertical Integration is incentived via the tax regime.
Tax on revenue not income.
Municipalities need to look at their policies that are creating barriers or friction for community beneficial organizations.
Yes. Profit margins are nowhere near 30% in groceries. More like low single digits, especially for essentials. IMO the greater importance of what Mandami has done in NY is not to lower prices but to increase access in food deserts.
30% off is still more expensive than you could buy from wholesale. It’s basically just going to be an Aldi in a neighborhood that can’t even get an Aldi to stay.
that, plus doing stuff like just giving away old bread for free.
It’s not like EVERYTHING has to be super cheap, if they can just provide cheap bread and beans that’s literally life saving!this.
I do not know what grocery store margins look like, but when I owned a game store, other than Magic The Gathering, my smallest margin was 35%. But 40% was more common, a lot of small companies gave 55%.
It wouldn’t affect it at all. Go buy cheap groceries and resell them. It’s not less than wholesale, so they’d lose money if they had access to the wholesale market.
This is bullshit. Some scaredy cat grocery store owner that can’t gouge prices anymore is scared and generating bullshit to cast shade on a good thing.
“But how will I buy another mansion this year?” - CEO of grocery store chain. Though in reality, it’s “How do I buy 4 more mansions, afford my trip to New Epstein-Trump island, and spend $10M on buying an election to outlaw cheap food?!?!?”
Bodegas in my town resell Aldi and Sam’s club stuff. As long as the public stores are not operating at a loss, it’s not a huge problem. Cheaper supply to the bodegas means they can sell cheaper too, and they’ll have to if they want to compete with the public stores anyway.
Costco & Sams Club originally began to support local businesses. Reselling was the point.
I would suggest you Google the average operating margin of a grocery store. They will 100% lose money and a lot of it. It will just be tax payer subsidized groceries. That’s fine if you want that, but let’s not pretend otherwise.
You don’t know NYC.
If hounding pay rent and don’t have shareholders stealing a huge chunk of the revenue, expenses are significantly less
Even if they save money on rent and that makes up for all the losses on food, that is still a government subsidy.
Grocery stores (and therefore shareholders of grocery stores) make one of the lowest profit margins of any industry in history. You would be better off complaining about Nestle and Tyson who actually made a ton of money during and after the pandemic.
You don’t know how retail works do you
One way around that is to limit purchases to reasonable quantities per household. So you can’t buy a full gross of $.25 mountain dew knock-off to sell outside in the first place. Makes it harder to start a side hustle. Not impossible but the required effort will be more of a hurdle.
I don’t think we should look at this local supermarket idea as one that needs to work 100% from the very start. They may make mistakes and they can fix them. One fix might be an ID check through the backdoor by using a local payment service that only residents have access to. When have politicians not changed their mind about something they said before. The payment service could just not collect and sell data.
The reason why I am quite forgiving is that I fear we are looking at a future where supermarket shopping will be automated to max out prices individually for every customer like the airlines have practiced with us for more than a decade. The cheap TV dinner you put in your cart has just gone up $2 before you had a chance to check out. Digital price tags can let them change prices like gas stations. In a pessimistic future you will scan and pay for every item the moment you lift it off the shelf at an algorithmically maxed out price. After all, we carry an identifier device with us wherever we go. Capitalists rejoice! Introducing an operation with reliably lower prices may be a good first step to correct for more troubling trends and dystopic threats.
If these Mamdaniesque ideas could be combined with wage growth in the lower rungs in the supply chains and a reduction of bonuses in their boardrooms, you’d have a more holistic approach to the redistribution of wealth many societies around the world badly need.
NYS outlawed that type of surveillance pricing a few months ago thankfully.
Thanks for the information. I didn’t know that.
Also if you outlawed all for profit food and drink grocery stores, it would help significantly
Grocery store scalpers are a thing? oO
If there is money to be made, there will be scalpers.
Well sure, but unlike tickets, you need storefronts to sell grocery goods. And traceability of items might be an issue. And consumers are going to tend to shop for lower prices. Then there’s the issue of quantity purchases… what rules might be in place to prevent such.
It just seems significantly trickier to scalp food unless you’re exporting it to a black market or something…
No, it’s a made up concept by idiots trying to smear the dude doing actual good work
See Venezuela.
They subsidized groceries, but people would buy them and sell in Colombia. Then you have to give stamps. It gets tricky to give cheap or free food in a global capitalist economy
Yeah at what point are they literally just participating in capitalism?
probably reselling it, or organized crime/shoplifters.
Usually there’s a big (your 30% as ballpark) price difference between suburb and store brand chains in pricing.
I don’t think the plan involves losing money. Competition to extortionist pricing that is closest to food deserts is what’s being solved. As to why stores just don’t take empty bottles and fill them with Hudson river water, it does cost money to do that, and establishment stores don’t have higher supply cost. They may have higher rental, decorations, and premium freshness/quality produce that costs more based on quality, but higher pricing is a choice based on lack of competition.










