I am ethically and morally opposed to gen AI as a concept. As far as the breaking point, let me explain. I’ve been a machinist for ~18 years. It’s been really bad for the last 9 years and I’ve more or less had to live off of savings from the good years (those savings are basically gone).
I’ve just recently gotten legitimate job offers for ~$125 an hour remote because I own a CNC. The catch is that I have to record all of the CAM programming and machine time in order to train an AI to replace potentially hundreds of thousands of jobs.
This fucking sucks. I’d love to sit on my ass forever at 43, but I absolutely fucking hate the potential that I could bring that would crush the working class and elevate the owning class.
I wish it wasn’t this hard, because I really do believe in socialism and have labored hard for a long time to make it happen - but there’s a chance I can put everything I have into true anarchism cause and make a legitimate difference.
Please help.
You won’t save the working class by yourself. Things are always changing, and under capitalism it is often for the worse. As another commenter said, CNC was the bane of lathe or mill machinists. There are still machinists, but now there are CNC operators as well. Who knows how things are going to be, but I can predict that there are still going to be lathe or mill machinists and CNC operators.
I’d say take the job. You live in the present. Being working class under capitalism necessarily means to be exploited by the powerful. It’s the same here. Work to put food on your table, while you organize, educate people politically, and participate to decision making.
I know he’s really busy right now, but you might try to get ahold of Benn Jordan about this and see if there’s anything he can do to help you send just exactly the right kind of wrong data.
He has some experience in poisoning AI datasets.
Someone is going to do it if you decline. I admire your principles but you have to eat… take the job, stay healthy, we’ll need you to help us fight the inevitable rise of the machines.
I really wanted to work the phrase G-Code Virus in there too, but I got nothing.
It really sucks. I hate it, but you’re probably right. I have no family at all, and even if it is a 1 year contract I can live for years off of $300k
Someone else will be a Nazi if you decline. Does that sound reasonable?
Stop that. You are on the same side and you’re both right. We need to fight as a group, not individually.
Yes and fighting is not “you might as well do it tbh”
Telling a man not to put food on his table is not a winning strategy.
Selling your values to the money-havers is not a winning strategy.
So you do not use up any fossil fuels? Only buying from anarchist co-ops? No Supermarkets for you? Only second hand clothing? O course your vegan too? And i really hope you don’t pay rent to anyone!
EVERYONE is aiding the 1% there is no way not to. How convinient that YOUR support is morally fine and you are wise enough to judge others without actually knowing a damn thing.
This is NOT how to build community, this is not how you get enough people to vote left(you know the thing that we ACTUALLY need to change something) this is one major reason why peoole think the left is a joke.
Automation is coming no matter what and it isn’t a problem when we manage to make left wing policies popular enough to run on and win, so we can tax the shit out of these companies and give the money back to the people in various forms.
Just stop with the blame game, ops decision does not make a difference at all for AI but he will not be more useful living on the street .
Is your dream for the future that everyone keeps being a wage slave ? Why not bring down all automation we had so far than?
Genuinely working on all of those things yeah! About to upgrade to an electric car actually lol. It’s not perfect but me and my partner do try. I think you personally value your comfort a lot more than the safety and happiness of other people. There is in fact plenty of survival out there for the jobless and underemployed, in fact life improves!
Are you dumb? This time it is not about aiding wealthy. He is going to take bread from poor. Do you get it now? Tell me if not, I will try to explain you like you are five
lol good one
No, i will not stop. Building community wont fix this disaster world and everyone who perpetuates it should be relentlessly bullied.
Also: you’re not working to build community with me so now I’m going to actively work against your interests 🥺🥺🥺 LOL
So you do not use up any fossil fuels? Only buying from anarchist co-ops? No Supermarkets for you? Only second hand clothing? O course your vegan too? And i really hope you don’t pay rent to anyone!
I hope you’re smart enough to realize this is a false equivalence by now but gonna leave this here just in case. Consuming products made by a shitty industry ≠ Working to advance another industry’s shittyness.
This is a thread about someone with a dilemma about the latter, the former is not a dilemma for most people. Because you can engage in harm reduction in one or several fields without giving up on harm reduction in another field, or engaging in it everywhere at once.
This is NOT how to build community, this is not how you get enough people to vote left(you know the thing that we ACTUALLY need to change something) this is one major reason why peoole think the left is a joke.
It’s because the education system (on average) sucks and people will vote against themselves and the betterment of society. Not because some randos on the internet think you shouldn’t work for an AI company.
Voting left does not require you to work for such a company. See above.
Automation is coming no matter what and it isn’t a problem when we manage to make left wing policies popular enough to run on and win, so we can tax the shit out of these companies and give the money back to the people in various forms.
It’s a global problem, local (even country-level) policies are not going to undo all the damage. The harm outweighs even the potential benefits, in my opinion. So it’s worth reducing it.
For that reason I hope OP can find employment elsewhere, but I’m not gonna live their life for them.
Godwin’s Law in record time. Principles mean nothing if you’re starving to death on the street. Better to get your piece and put it to good work.
They’re not starving though
Burning through savings and 43 equals food insecurity coming around the corner, or doing other shitty odd jobs.
They’re using Uber and door dash data to train ai too.
That other person will be a Nazi if you accept, too. The job only goes to a finite number of people.
It wouldn’t be the internet if someone didn’t pull this one off the shelf. 👏
All those ancient VCRs waking up to record static…
Clocks still blinking 12:00 😉
AI video editor is still needed for the podcast I turned down. You would do it because you are a shill but that’s not provable.
Show me the data!!
No idea what you’re babbling about but clearly you intend to die mad about it, so don’t let me get in your way.
I’ll explain, without artist input these companies have nothing because of how modern AI copyright works. Being an AI trainer is taking jobs away from people with no promise of an income or future. It’s a short term high and has severe long term implications that are really obvious if you use your brain cells for two seconds at all.
TLDR
I don’t believe for a second you will ever fight any robot ever because you already don’t… at all.
LOL. I’m hurt, while I did read the TLDR first, I wouldn’t skip the body, you took the time to write it, reading it’s the least I could do.
I’m not sure what the intention of OPs employer is… it definitely strikes me as odd. I’m touched you recognize the artestry in a machinist’s job, many people wouldn’t :-) I’m assuming that the market for this training data is China but perhaps not… certainly they have enough domestic talent in that feild. But I’m basing my assumption on the promises that Xhorse and others have been making in the “desktop CNC” space. Maybe it’s a USDM company like Hass that’s clearly running a bit scared ATM.
Your robot analogy is almost clunky but since I went all Terminator first I can’t really fault you there ;-)
I’m not exactly proud of the advice I gave, but I certainly don’t have the money to help out OP until he can find a job that aligns with my principles —believe me, we’re not that far off here. I’m both fascinated and appalled by the AI revolution.
I suppose I should have said (in my original post) that OP should keep looking for something else while doing the training gig, but I’m doubtful that would have made much difference in your sentiment. You seem to be quite zellous in your beliefs, and I admire that. A battle of this scope takes all kinds. On that note, I need some coffee to keep fighting this one, TTYL ;-)
You can take the $125 and poison their data by making a few mistakes every time. Just do it as inefficiently as possible, as you’re billed by the hour. You’ll make more money and they’ll have more work and less useful data.
Sure, by an ethical/moral standpoint that works. From the legal standpoint, however, if I did that I’d be sued to the point where I have no option but to live out my life in prison. This kind of thing sounds great on paper. In practice? I’m not fucking going back.
Why are you so scared? Don’t sign a contract which tells you to do it as efficiently as possible. Just be incompetent. It’s not illegal to be incompetent. Mark Zuckerberg wasted 1 billion dollars with his Metaverse shit and he’s still one of the most powerful and wealthy CEOs.
That’s called “weaponised incompetence” or “malicious compliance”. If you do it right, they don’t have any basis to sue you. Just fake it. Imagine you’re just very bad at your job.
Capitalism often controls through fear. The fear of being sacked. The fear of being sued. In the end, the consequences for being bad are not as painful as you’d imagine.
Iwish I could bring myself to this, but I actually rely give a fuck and have some pride in what I do. I wish I wasn’t principled, but I spent years as an apprentice to get to where I am at and I’ll be damned if I put my name on shoddy work.
I’ll be damned if I put my name on shoddy work.
It’s good work, though.
If you do it right, they don’t have any basis to sue you. Just fake it.
Except for this public conversation.
We’re just clowns doing clown things. That’s a different guy they sent the offer to. Why would it be their account?
No one said you’re a good machinist. So you take 0.005 passes rather than 0.020 passes and set your cutting speed lower. Your rational is it saves your tools. No on is saying cut every thing dry. But that would work too.
Way too easy to fix and way too obvious. A competent machinist will fix this by just changing a single value. You have to introduce less obvious and more insidious errors.
But its not to train competent machinists. Odds are good it will be run by minimum wage slaves who know almost nothing about machining. Tfats what the ai is for afterall.
Yes, but if they find out the data is shit, an LLM or another competent machinist can fix it easily. I’d add errors LLMs can’t spot, and humans take long to find.
You cannot be sued for doing your job badly. That’s insane lol
In the US at least (which sounds like the OP’s country), you can be sued for anything and everything, regardless of merit.
That’s the fun paranoia we live in reading headlines of lots of lawsuits, but no, we do actually have workers’ rights and such things as unlawful lawsuits in the US. If people were getting sued for being shitty at their job, we wouldn’t have great places like Taco Bell
Did the shareholders sue Mark Zuckerberg and Elon Musk yet? Seriously asking, I’m not an American
Data is data. Mistakes are valuable training data.
poison the data

This is the way. Contaminate it all. If AI will kill us all, better it be born of our own contaminated hatred for the owners of the means of production.
Based
My thoughts exactly.
Do it. A lot of these AI companies are going to go bankrupt. Companies are paying a premium for data on the hope that it’ll make them lots of money, but real world applications do not always follow. A lot of these companies are ill equipped to deliver what they claim.
Even the big AI companies are struggling to match the promised gains versus their costs.
Someone will take the job, so take it. Its basically speculative investors money. Maybe they will succeed maybe they won’t, but you can have the money and need the money.
The models will survive those bankruptcies. The models will get bought up for nothing by the next wave of AI companies - companies that won’t waste money creating new models or planet-scale data centers, but will still let people outsource human, creative work to digital slaves.
If OP takes the job, they should thin about tactics to poison the data set. Systematically add useless moves to the tool paths. Home after every segment. Random speeds. Extra coordinate changes. I’m sure they can think of other bad-but-works processes.
My problem with that is that if I do this correctly, it could mean hundreds of thousands of jobs from people that have potentially spent decades making a trade. It’s harder than just me wanting money.
Then don’t do it correctly. You’re basically doing your peers a favor if you poison the data.
I might get grilled for this point of view…
The car dramatically reduced the demand for horse shoe makers. Perhaps you’re lucky to be on the car side of the equation? Horses are still great, but most people prefer cars.
It’s a good analogy because cars enabled globalism, more exploitation and poisoned billions of people with nitrous oxides, lead and particulates. Cars lead to cancer. We should be on the train side of the equation…
There is no side to be on, people will do the more convinient thing and cars were not obviously that dangerous and there are OBVIOUSLY positives to car use over horses.
Is your argument we should have forsaken any modernity since the first humans?
No, my argument is that humanity should stop doing dumb things when they find out they’re dumb.
The irony is that CNC did this to the guys who manually worked milling machines and turned lathes.
Surely there are already generic CNC emulators? I had an internship 15 years ago for a CNC company that had an emulator for their tools. I also know it was leaked on the pirate bay, which everyone thought was hilarious. Pirating the emulator is worthless without the very expensive CNC machine.
I really doubt there is anything an AI can learn from your videos, and I suspect the AI company has no idea what they are doing. Take the job, get the money (in cash), and wait for them to crater. Dont be surprised if the job dries up long before the term though.
I ran a hard mill at one point and occasionally a cnc lathe. That was 20 years ago and there was a ton of automation. In fact, it was mostly automation. I’d indicate the die or punch into the machine, load the igis file, and then go sweep the floor for the next 8 hours. There were a few things that automation couldnt handle (it would leave sharp edges, for example), but I think most of that was the fault of the dude that built the igis file in CAD. So Id be curious as to what AI would do that it wasnt already doing way back then.
Anyhow, didn’t love that job and left quickly.
When I worked my CNC job there was lots of talk of light out manufacturing. Factories with busy machines, and no humans, so no need for lighting for the useless squishy humans. Its always been something that engineering has been working towards, it was just a lot more gradual until recently.
There are generic CNC emulators. They’ve been around for a long time (like 15 years, as you said). The difference is that that they will do the grunt work, but a human needs to make the tool paths actually viable. The difference is that with actual professional tools like MasterCAM, it has been cutting out that intern for just as long but a cost of thousands of dollars per seat. What this has the potential to do, if I do it correctly, is even push out those incredibly expensive MasterCAM seats. I could cost hundreds of thousands of jobs if I do this correctly.
The emulator in had could do tool path correction, and tell you when you would crash. And they were working on lights out automation when I left, albeit classical programming, not AI. Was easier for us given we only supported a very limited number of machine models though.
I suspect, and you’ll know better, but these guys dont know shit about machining, which is why they are coming to you. I suspect that they have no idea how large the problem space actually is, and they are just going to try to brute force an AI solution.
And I dont think that is viable for machining.
Whether you do this correctly or not won’t change that they dont know what they are doing. My guess is you can give them exactly what they ask for, and after a month or 2 it won’t work, and theyll ask you to redo it all slightly differently, and youll go through that cycle until they run out of money.
You may as well take their money. And be smart about it. You need a top end dSLR camera to record accurate footage, get them to send you one. You need a top end PC and a high res and high framerate monitor to process the footage.
Do you think you could do it in a way such that you introduce suboptimal patterns into the training data, to make the model less viable and less reliable? Because poisoning training data is something that a lot of people are starting to do in a lot of domains.
I don’t think so, because they want a viable physical product which can be measured accurately.
Make it twice, record the bad one, ship the good one.
… Until ArtCraft clones it for free?
Do it, and then after you get paid, release all the programming and machine time recordings online into the public domain. Then at the very least, it might be used to train an open-source AI model that anyone can use. Or better yet, collaborate with the folks working on the FreeCAD CAM workbench and get the ball rolling yourself if you think this sort of AI CAM thing is feasible.
Their catch is they’ll say your footage isn’t suitable for training and will only pay for a small portion that they claim can be used for training
Yep, try to be paid by the hour and not get scammed, OP!
My dad was a machinist. I know automation for their jobs is highly desired. In an ideal socialist world, we would need experts to automate everything for us anyway, so the work you do is laying the ground work for that future to exist; we know it’s going to be misused, I would say do it, document things as best you can for the next generation in a common book you keep to yourself.
Additionally, we know AI is pretty shit, Its more likely there will be a robotics breakthrough that will get people there. I think if you go in and get paid, and keep your eyes open for ways to sabotage the data set. (Being inefficient or bad at your job is a way to keep the gig going as long as possible)… there’s hope.
It’s going to happen anyways. You’re not complicit in what’s happening if you take advantage of this opportunity that’s presented itself to you.
This is a new industrial revolution, and it’s going to displace jobs like yours. It sucks, but it’s happening.
There’s a shit load of theft and awful stuff happening right now and that’s abhorrent, but paying you for data is 100% legit and how every author and artist etc should have been compensated for the training data that’s gone into the machine learning black hole.
At the end of the day it’s up to you, but I wouldn’t worry about this one. They’re paying you for legitimate use. Eventually folks like yourself will be much rarer/specialized.
Don’t say he won’t be complicit because he totally would be. He’d knowingly accept the job and lay the work. Saying it’s gonna happen anyway might be a cope for this decision, but it’s a decision he alone takes with conscience, wether it bothers him or not.
eye roll Get it that this isn’t the right place for a nuanced discussion on this, or probably even the right platform, but I’ll say it anyways.
Congress is complicit in the grand theft of IP by not stopping it in its tracks. So is every employee that did the theft itself, every lawyer that helped arrange the financial details, etc. All the big data collection companies that sold your info are complicit in the rape of your privacy.
But the fact is that there are real technological innovations with the advent of modern machine learning, and it’s dumb to lump the march of innovation in with all the worst parts of whatever “AI” is.
OP isn’t complicit in the obsolescence of the actual work he does - that’s falsely assigning judgement and negative connotation to a plain fact: the industry he works in is changing. Eventually there will be many fewer machinists that do the work he does, and AI will do a lot of the work that used to be done by human machinists. That in and of itself isn’t a good or bad thing (it just IS), even if there’s TONS of negative externalities (environmental, economic control, loss of jobs, whatever). So no, OP isn’t complicit in some downfall of his industry if he sells his knowledge to train AI models.
Now, if he stole this data from employees in a company or something and sold it, he would be complicit in the theft of that information. But not necessarily the industry change that is coming.
Yes OP us and you write long strings of bullshit to cope I think. Job opening I turned down training AI in video editing is still open. You are projecting big time. You would take it.
Based off of the information provided in only the OP, yeah I probably would take it if was in their position. I don’t see anything morally wrong with literally being paid for providing industry training for specialized skills for machine learning.
Everyone removedes like “I want AI to do the dishes for me so I can do art, not do art for me so I can do dishes” yeah that’s a legit feeling but the reality is that there was tons of art to steal to train models on and zero data about how your body moves when you’re doing dishes to train models on. So we got art and writing and music theft and the destruction of web search, because all that information was available and easy to steal. When I say FUCK AI that’s what I’m talking about, along with all the other disgusting business practices across the board.
Being paid to train machine learning models to do your job in the future isn’t selling out. Tech moves on, jobs go away. It’s the HOW that evolution happens that we should cast moral judgement on, not the fact that it happens in the first place.
No mf don’t act like you’re pro-rights and life when you’re not offering a reasonable alternative. Artists lost our jobs and now we live on the streets while you consume shit trained on our work and talk about how useless we are now and how we have to accept that. Accept that I fucking hate you and will never ever consider you anything less than a fascist if you can’t resist the most basic thing to resist ever (robots designed by fascists meant to make art and propaganda specifically to embolden the warmongering capitalist class). Like yeah of course you feel this way, you probably get all your advice from a fucking Elon musk robot lmao. You kept letting it slide.
Wut lol
You’re complete bullshit. My post is easy to understand you’re just a moron.
Sounds like a perfect opportunity to poison the AI in inconspicuous ways, my friend.
Im just saying, you could spearhead a revolution and make dough at the same time.
Just do it wrong. Half ass the fuck out of it and milk it for what you can before they catch on. Fuck those pigs
There’s huge instability in the market. So there’s no telling how long that position would even last









