Welcome again to everybody. Make yourselves at home. In the time-honoured tradition of our group, here is the weekly discussion thread.
☭ Matrix homeserver and space
☭ Find theory on ProleWiki, marxists.org, Anna’s Archive
Welcome again to everybody. Make yourselves at home. In the time-honoured tradition of our group, here is the weekly discussion thread.
☭ Matrix homeserver and space
☭ Find theory on ProleWiki, marxists.org, Anna’s Archive
Do you all think the Western is a fundementally reactionary genre? I was big into Westerns a while ago, and though I was always aware of the reality behind the old West to some extent, seeing all the abhorrent shit Isreal has been doing and continues to do really hardened me against it I think.
Any genre could be reactionary depending on the creative force behind it. Most war films are reactionary and come from a western perspective, but then there are films like “Come and See”. Westerns, more often than not fall into reactionary ideas and stereotypes but that does not mean films can not be made that discuss this era of time with reality instead of propaganda
Walker (I think I would count it as a western. Good satire piece on imperialism)
Black Robe (kind of a western)
McCabe & Mrs. Miller (Excellent film on the realities of the time, just depressing)
The Proposition (An australian western)
There Will be Blood
Blood Meridian (A really good book that serves as a deconstruction of the genocide of Native Americans)
I think since Westerns are largely an American invention it does make sense that the majority of westerns are usually presented in a way that paints the settlers as heroes. I feel that most Americans are not very concerned with how Native Americans are presented, most Americans don’t even know any Native Americans. The most you’ll get from an American is “The natives got a raw deal” and that’s the extent of their support, most aren’t even aware of the current conditions Native American tribes live under today in reservations.
Western as a genre has fluctuated throughout its history. It has many subgenres within it dealing with different stories and themes and such.
Many are pro-settler, a few are pro-indigenous, but most I think sit in a middle category where they’re more interested in telling a brutal story in a brutal period of a brutal region.
The middle category you describe is a subgenre in itself that originated only in the mid 60s with the Italian Spaghetti Western. At it’s heart, brutal stories and a brutal setting are the antithesis of the original golden-age Western, making the Spaghetti Western such an immense tonal shift that the original Sergio Leonne films effectively created a new genre in their own right.
Spaghetti Westerns had the same effect on Westerns that the Cyberpunk board game, Blade Runner film, and Necromancer book had on Sci-fi. Once those works came out, virtually ALL sci-fi from that point onward became rehashes of those three works. Now, if you ask someone how they would define the Sci-fi genre, any pre-80s influence is virtually absent save for scant influences from works such as Star Trek that are closer in feel to fantasy than the contemporary Sci-fi genre.
Some were even produced in socialist states, although the ones set in America reproduce the stereotypes, especially the noble savage trope: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ostern
The ones set in the USSR are less reactionary:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Auj_u7wEyw8
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=e0ECy37ayUw
I found YouTube links in your comment. Here are links to the same videos on alternative frontends that protect your privacy:
Link 1:
Link 2:
It depends on the film. I saw Quigley Down Under, and it was very pro-Aboriginal.
For the most part, yes, probably.
This was why Revisionist Western was created which made Westerns less reactionary, although they still tend to be reactionary themselves.