Crossposted from https://fedia.io/m/[email protected]/t/4518262
Inspired by this thread where at least five different libs made the same point and responded the same way when I tried to poke their bubble. Seriously CTRL+F my username or the word “voter” it’s downright surreal. The hivemindness of the affair was also pretty weird, but I’m not one to meme the same interaction twice.


I see, liberalism was created for the purpose of upholding an economic system which would not exist until nearly a century later.
Genius!
Oh boy. One of you people.
No, Talcosis. Liberalism was created to solve a systemic economic imbalance caused by how power was distributed in feudalism. The resulting system that Liberalism produced from its first principles (namely, people who go out and make a lot of money should be able to do whatever they want with that money) resulted in what we now call capitalism. That’s why Liberalism ascends in near lock-step with mercantilism. Because it’s a philosophy driven primarily by the aggrieved merchant class.
Oh, okay.
So why use the original definition of conservatism but not the original definition of liberalism?
Say more. I think I am using the original definition of Liberalism. What is the original definition, as you understand it, and how does it differ from what I have provided?
The right to self determination.
Yeah, so like I said, that comes from the economic pressure built up by merchants who were free to go make their fortune but not free to buy power and change society. A lot of liberal theory was developed from observing charter cities, which were places rich merchants and bankers built after they convinced a king to sell them a charter to a piece of land. They created all sort of new ways of operating on this theory of self-determination. Except it was only positive self-determination for the rich and landed. The workers were “self-determined” in that they could choose which abusive rich merchant they could work for.
This is what I mean. Liberalism is internally contradictory because self-determination and private property are diametrically opposed when you scale them up. Claiming natural right to murder anyone who steps foot on a piece of land, and to pay people to do that murdering for you, and to pass that right down through inheritance, or sell that right to the highest bidder, is only self-determination for the minority. For the majority of people, their lives are determined by what the ultraminority rich allow them to have, and of course the smartest move is for the ultraminority rich to collaborate, even without direct and explicit coordination, in making sure the majority are always weak, divided, focused on their own survival, and fighting each other instead of the rich.
That’s liberalism, from the beginning. It’s never been anything except that.
Oh, don’t worry, I understand exactly why you’d like to keep the conversation focused on economics and not consider at all what it means for the mechanisms of state oppression.
I don’t think you do, actually. Liberalism has a very bloody history of state repression whenever it took root. 100 - 150 years of abject poverty of the masses resulted in the labor movement and gave birth to Marxism because liberal state repression was just that devastating.
Remember, private property rights are enforced by the state. They are not natural in any way. They are legal fictions created by and enforced by the state on behalf of the minority of owners.
sigh
If you’re going to use the original definition of conservative, why do you insist on not using the original definition of liberal?