TERF anti-masker Gloria de la Cruz
First of all, I have no idea who Gloria de la Cruz is.
Secondly, I can say from my firsthand experience, neither Gloria la Riva nor Claudia de la Cruz are transphobic anti-maskers.
But you’re clearly not engaging seriously or in good faith, so this is pretty unproductive.
[citation needed]
What do you think Socialist Reconstruction is about? Appealing to the bourgeois US government?
This is clearly rooted in an idealist lack of understanding of the actual present state of various national liberation struggles. As much as I wish it wasn’t the case, no matter how low your opinion of the PSL is, at best those groups aren’t any closer to achieving revolutionary change than the PSL are. That being said, the PSL explicitly aims to organize alongside, and often deferring to, those elements of national liberation struggles that aren’t completely reactionary guided by the principle of the right of all nations to self determination.
Be specific, what “settler leadership” is saying that? Because that’s news to me, and flies in the face of the actual direct experience I have with these people.
Is what you’re saying that any party containing “settlers” is counter revolutionary? Who are settlers, by your definition? Is it just white people, or are you including anyone who is not indigenous? And in either case, are you saying that any “settler” has no place in revolutionary politics? Please, explain your vision for what a real revolutionary organization in the United States should be doing.
Idk much about FRSO, I’ve heard they’re fine but I can’t speak personally to it. It’s definitely worth forming your own opinion on PSL, since this guy wages a personal crusade against them so you’re not exactly getting an unbiased perspective. In my experience, I strongly disagree with his perspective on the class and national composition of the PSL, and he has yet to provide a more substantive critique. In my experience, PSL are a party that is genuinely composed of the multinational working class of the United States.
You’re conflating a lot of things here, so be specific. Who is saying things like “Israeli and Palestinian working class unite”? Who isn’t recognizing the unique character of the black working class compared with other nations and especially white Americans? Because you’re saying CPUSA, PSL, and FRSO but I guarantee it doesn’t apply to all of them.
The exchange value is low, because nobody wants burnt cookies or shit pies. But if people did want to buy burnt cookies and shit pies, the exchange value would correlate with the amount of labor required to produce them.