The fallacy that if you don’t do something, you must think there’s something wrong with doing that thing
For example, when weed used to be illegal in Canada, I didn’t do it because I didn’t want to get arrested. I had an argument with my aunt, who insisted I must think weed is “evil” even though I said nothing to indicate I thought it was morally wrong. I use it quite frequently now, but I’m sure there are a lot of people who think it’s morally okay to do and don’t because of many different reasons including that they just don’t feel like it.
I don’t play video games, build model airplanes, or dance ballet. I don’t see anything wrong with those things, I’m just not into them. Nobody can be into every possible hobby.
I listened to a call-in show on YouTube where a guy insisted the female host must think prostitution is morally wrong because she herself wasn’t a prostitute. She said “I’m also not a concert pianist, that doesn’t mean I think there’s anything wrong with being a concert pianist”.
Its partly a form of this: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Conjunction_fallacy
And partly this: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Affirming_the_consequent
I don’t think it’s has a name, but it can be summed up as “(avail)ability does not dictate morality”.
It’s the opposite to the equally valid “inclusion does not equal endorsement” which I remember someone mentioning in regards to criticism of some historical game or TV show that portrayed racism.
I hadn’t considered this fallacy relation to the inclusion equals endorsement fallacy. That’s an interesting one too. As a writer, I sometimes worry about being seen as endorsing everything a character says or does. Sometimes characters do bad things so that the moral of thevstory can be about why it’s bad. Or sometimes characters do bad things because they’re the villain. Or because the story isn’t that serious and it’s supposed to make you laugh. Sometimes I feel pressure to make the narrative either condone or condemn every character action, but sometimes maybe the story shouldn’t do that. Sometimes it’s okay for the story to just say “this happened” instead of “it’s good that this happened” or “it’s bad that this happened”.
It’s important to recognize that including something in a story isn’t necessarily an endorsement, and also to realize that excluding something from a story isn’t necessarily condemnation. The Hunger Games books have yet to feature a major same-sex romance. I doubt that means the authour is against it. It just doesn’t happen to be a part of the stories she’s telling.
If a reader thinks anything you write is endorsed by you, that’s their own bias showing up.
I mean that’s just effing stupid to assume that an author endorses the murder commited by a character (for example).
We all get to be stupid, sometime, but some people just full-on embrace it.
Your two examples here are prostitution and weed. Both have had laws written about them, quite often to ban them. Both have been in the crosshair of organised religion. Building model airplanes has never been that controversial. Individual video games may have had similar discussions around them but never the whole idea of video games. So I think this isn’t a fallacy so much as good old human biases that make people jump to conclusions.
Good point. Perhaps people just make that assumption when the action in question is widely considered morally wrong. Pointing out examples of other mundane things I don’t do is to illustrate how silly the assumption is


