Welcome again to everybody. Make yourselves at home. In the time-honoured tradition of our group, here is the weekly discussion thread.
☭ Matrix homeserver and space
☭ Find theory on ProleWiki, marxists.org, Anna’s Archive
Welcome again to everybody. Make yourselves at home. In the time-honoured tradition of our group, here is the weekly discussion thread.
☭ Matrix homeserver and space
☭ Find theory on ProleWiki, marxists.org, Anna’s Archive
Silly question
So, the reason why it’s so hard to create a currency for a Minecraft server (or, in other words, create a commodity exchange market) is that it’s hard to find a reason for division of labor?
Like, if a single player can acquire any item in a reasonable amount of time, then there wouldn’t be any reason for a market.
Because currencies that are not backed by a state are not currencies, they are just exchange commodities.
Also, in the real world things have value because they take labor to produce and the resources needed to make them are finite. Many resources in Minecraft are not finite and some can be automatically infinitely duplicated, therefore their labor-embodied value will be zero and trading them is just a LARP.
That’s interesting. Do you know if there’s any theory that talks about that? Still haven’t reached the role of the State in the Capital.
When I wrote my comment I was thinking about this part from Chapter 1:
And yeah, Minecraft world resources are either infinite or practically infinite, so I agree that my initial question was moot. However, I was mostly curious about how currency would develop in a game.
There’s a lot of videos on Youtube from people trying make a currency for Minecraft and none of them touch division of labor. Also there’s one from an Austrian Economics enthusiast. It was a good source of comedy.
What Marx is saying there is quite evidently true. If you do not have division of labor and everyone is essentially self-sufficient then there is no need for a currency.
What i was pointing out is that historically in every society that has had some form of currency, whether it was ancient China or Mesopotamian city states, there was a state or state-like authority with monopolistic control over the production of the currency and which served as the final backstop of confidence that the currency you trade for today could still be used tomorrow to trade for other goods. Otherwise the system does not work.
A currency is only useful if it keeps its value somewhat constant, so you need to restrict and manage its production. If you use shells or (standardized and regulated) bits of metal you have to have a state monopoly on the production of that resource. You cannot have people who independently mine that resource just flood the system with large amounts of it, nor can you have speculation wildly fluctuating its “price”. This problem of fluctuation was historically solved by stamping those bits of metal (or more generally marking whatever thing you used as currency with some form of unique identifier) so that the value of the coin can be divorced from the value of the metal (or whichever other resource) it is made from. And then you have to strictly control against forgery.
Finally, you have to have some form of authority that guarantees that even if everyone else around you no longer has confidence in the currency, that the state will still back its value, essentially promising you that no matter what happens you will still be able to exchange that currency for goods. Otherwise you can end up in a situation where your “currency” is a purely speculative asset whose value can drop to zero when public confidence in it collapses.
Edit: Oh, and i forgot to add that one of the most important functions of money and why it arose in the first place was and continues to be to pay taxes to the state.
Thanks for the detailed answer. Really appreciate it.
the tldr: I think simulating trade systems in any game is hard.
When you wrote about the role of the State in standardizing currency, I tried to think about how it got its role.
Like, maybe there existed some early priestly religious class that started this sort of administration/standardization of trade. Maybe that’s where the State evolved from.
Also from your comment:
I assume you mean something like cryptocurrency.
You might be interested in Michael Hudson’s writings on this subject: https://michael-hudson.com/2018/04/palatial-credit-origins-of-money-and-interest/
Yes. “Cryptocurrency” is not and will never be currency. It does not fulfil the basic functional requirements.
Thanks for the article
It’s best to play like a commune and share the infinte resources the game provides
Exactly!
I have seen a lot of videos of people trying to create a currency for Minecraft.
Capitalism is already too much on real life, why bring it to a game?
I agree