Crossposted from https://fedia.io/m/[email protected]/t/4518262
Inspired by this thread where at least five different libs made the same point and responded the same way when I tried to poke their bubble. Seriously CTRL+F my username or the word “voter” it’s downright surreal. The hivemindness of the affair was also pretty weird, but I’m not one to meme the same interaction twice.


No, Tal. That’s not what liberal means. It’s just not. I know you are taking it to mean what you want it to mean, but that’s not what it means.
Marxism is very specifically a critique of Liberalism, not an extension of it. It specifically asks why did Liberalism claim certain values and aspirations but fail completely to deliver on them, and then it explains how Liberalism is internally contradictory because it puts private property rights at the same level as the right to free expression and ultimately the reliance on private property as a source of power is antithetical to the values of universal liberation.
That’s why we use the word liberation instead of the word liberal in political philosophy contexts. Liberalism is not a liberatory political philosophy. Marxism is.
So it’s not that you don’t understand the concept, you just want a linguistic purity test capable of excluding people that mostly agree with you. Apart from the statism.
Good luck.
No, Tal. You are the one who insisted that I was using a term incorrectly and insisted on not explaining your reasoning for a dozens comments until you finally made up your own definition of a term and then got upset that I was using the term as it has been historically defined.
I don’t have a purity test. Ignorance is welcome in my world. We are all born ignorant of so many things. Ignorance is where we all start. But to declare someone is wrong while being so arrogant about your own ignorance is not something I am going to just say “OK, let’s use your definition of a term and let’s also pretend that your fantasy about history is reality”. That’s not a purity test. You aren’t being wronged here.
We may in fact agree in lots of things, but the fact you are willing to post from total ignorance, refuse to explain your reasoning, and then act like I have a purity test means that I will never find out if we agree on things because you can’t hold a fucking discourse to save your life.