I know these Deng = Chinese Khrushchev revisionism takes are ultra but still though? (Def might be Controversial)

  • Cowbee [he/they]@lemmygrad.ml
    link
    fedilink
    arrow-up
    42
    ·
    27 days ago

    It’s from those that oppose Reform & Opening Up. If you agree with modern China’s reforms, then this statement is wrong. If you disagree, then it’s correct. Personally, I see Reform & Opening Up as a return to more classical Marxist views of economics than the Gang of Four period, and agree that calling Deng a Gorbachev or anything is an ultraleft take. For further evidence, socialism still exists in China and is rising, unlike the USSR.

    • loathsome dongeater@lemmygrad.ml
      link
      fedilink
      English
      arrow-up
      17
      ·
      27 days ago

      I see it not as more or less marxist but as adopting a different approach to nation-building. In a world without USSR, the communist bloc was essentially halved in strength. Could hostility towards and isolation from the west work? Ultra-left folk tend to think so. But it is indisputable that the influx of capital and technology from the west has turned China into such a powerhouse that China is essentially the only sovereign country in the world now besides the USA.

      • Cowbee [he/they]@lemmygrad.ml
        link
        fedilink
        arrow-up
        25
        ·
        edit-2
        26 days ago

        I realize I am being a bit provocative in describing Reform & Opening Up more classically Marxist, so I’ll elaborate a bit more. As we both know, the economic basis of marketization is decentralized and disparate production, while the economic basis of planned economy is in advanced and centralized production. So as to not introduce antagonisms, the PRC marketizes the underdeveloped sectors deliberately so as to exert strong oversight.

        The USSR, for all of its progressive and correct moves, was more of a siege economy for its entire existence. It worked remarkably well, but de facto private property existed in black markets, and since these were not a legal part of the system, they progressed without state control, only the USSR stamping them out where they saw them. This led to a surge in class struggle with a CPSU that could not accurately control them thanks to reforms by Gorbachev and the historical nihilism created by Khrushchev.

        The DPRK is an excellent foil, in that they have not done either. They are taking the correct approach as an economy under siege, as did the USSR, in maintaining an overwhelmingly planned economy. Marketization in siege economies can be dangerous. However, the DPRK watched what happened to the USSR post-Stalin and instead developed along their own path, one that focuses on ideological training and sovereignty without resorting to historical nihilism or eroding the ideological foundation of the party.

        Overall, these are all Marxist, all socialist. But China’s approach today is the smoothest, because it does not have those same antagonisms at play when it comes to decentralized and centralized production, hence their heightened stability and influence on a world scale, as the world gradually erodes the basis of imperialism and progresses. Imperialism is on its last legs, hopefully, and China’s interconnection is a valuable part of that process.

    • cfgaussian@lemmygrad.ml
      link
      fedilink
      arrow-up
      22
      ·
      27 days ago

      This is really the crux of the matter. Khrushchev made up lies about Stalin and in doing so undermined the ideological foundation of the rule of the party. Deng never did the same to Mao.

      • burlemarx@lemmygrad.ml
        link
        fedilink
        arrow-up
        20
        ·
        edit-2
        27 days ago

        The lies about Stalin shattered communist parties abroad, because most of the hard liners were demoralized, while revisionists and liquidationists gained strength. I never understood the impact of the secret speech until I understood that after it there were splits happening in communist parties all over the world. Most of the hardliners aligned themselves with Maoist China at the time.

        In Brazil, the PCB changed their name from “Partido Comunista do Brasil” to “Partido Comunista Brasileiro”, while the hardliners moved to PCdoB (Partido Comunista do Brasil). The difference in name is subtle, but it implied that PCB would go towards a nationalist and legalist strategy while PCdoB would remain internationalist and tied to the whole communist movement.

        • cfgaussian@lemmygrad.ml
          link
          fedilink
          arrow-up
          20
          ·
          27 days ago

          Yes. It’s almost impossible to imagine nowadays but the communist movement was incredibly strong and popular worldwide in the aftermath of the USSR heroic victory in WW2, and Khrushchev’s lie-filled speech drove a dagger through the heart of the international communist movement splintering and it horrifically damaging its image.

          • RedPartisan@lemmygrad.ml
            link
            fedilink
            arrow-up
            8
            ·
            27 days ago

            I wonder if Turkish communist parties largely preferring Albania and China helped us mitigate the amount of opportunism that plagues Western communists today. Even today primary factions are Maoist, Hoxhaist, or kind of patsoc.

            • cfgaussian@lemmygrad.ml
              link
              fedilink
              arrow-up
              15
              ·
              27 days ago

              Whatever the reason, those are definitely preferable to our Eurocommunists. We have a serious chauvinism problem in Europe which leads even most of our communists to turn into little more than spicy socdems.

            • burlemarx@lemmygrad.ml
              link
              fedilink
              arrow-up
              7
              ·
              27 days ago

              My experience with Hoxhaists and Maoists is usually mixed or bad. Usually very sectarian. Not to mention that people creating a platform on adventurism and in a distorted application of protracted people’s war.

              • RedPartisan@lemmygrad.ml
                link
                fedilink
                arrow-up
                4
                ·
                24 days ago

                They are very sectarian for sure, Turkish communist movements are extremely fragmented. But at least they aren’t revisionist, I’ll take what I can get in this climate.

                • burlemarx@lemmygrad.ml
                  link
                  fedilink
                  arrow-up
                  3
                  ·
                  edit-2
                  23 days ago

                  One of the reasons that Marx wanted the communist league (previously league of the just) to go public is because he wanted to focus in open propaganda work for the working class and to make them join the movement. The league of communists was a private club led by a minority of Jacobins, and as such they were not a significant group in France, not enough to gain power. And he was adamant that the proletarian revolution would come in stages, and it wasn’t a minoritarian group like the Blanquists the ones that would be able to implement communism and socialism by sheer force of will or by conspiracy.

                  When the proletarian movement rose to a point it became significant, with some militant parties like the German Social Democrats, then the movement started being joined by opportunists of all sorts and then revisionists that wanted to twist Marx theory to totally different directions, like chauvinistic nationalism (like the Zionists did), or economism, or reformism. Then Lenin reinforced the need to fight those trends and the importance of having the correct political line to bar these trends from creeping on the org and then created the first real communist revolutionary organization. It made sense at the time because the socialists and communists were a huge political force by then.

                  The problem of these ultra left orgs is that they live in a time the communist movement is not significant. So they become dwarfs in the proletarian movement and they do not grow to become a significant force. So they have the problems that Marx had during his time, but want to apply the solution that Lenin had at his time. Political lines, strategy and tactics are not a static thing and they need to change if they are not contributing for the growth of the revolutionary party and revolutionary conscience among the proletariat.

                  But this is a problem for all socialist orgs worldwide. So we need to review some of our tactics and grow to the material conditions of the 21st century.

    • 挂路灯人@lemmy.ml
      link
      fedilink
      arrow-up
      29
      ·
      27 days ago

      I love this interview it has so many amazing quotes but my favourite has to be:

      Fallaci: And the Gang of Four are alive, is that correct? Jiang Qing is alive, is that correct?

      Deng: She eats — quite a bit — and sleeps. In prison, naturally. And from that you may deduce that she is alive.

  • amemorablename@lemmygrad.ml
    link
    fedilink
    arrow-up
    21
    ·
    27 days ago

    Had Deng been a Khrushchev, the world would surely have a much weaker China, possibly one splintered by civil war or in the awkward position Russia is in, of anti-imperialist for survival but ultimately capitalist.

    At the time of Deng taking power, it makes more sense to me that people would have been torn, as the substance of things had not unfolded yet and communism, which had already been under siege, was now going to try an approach that could break the siege without direct war, in order to build the productive forces; to become more capable rather than kept weak and trapped.

    The way I see it, and others can correct me if this is distorted or oversimplified, is that the CPC’s approach was continuously one of gradual transition. Not to say it was clean and without conflict, but that the process was careful and planned at each stage. And so for the Reform and Opening Up stage, they planted seeds and tended to the growth of the economy, allowing capital to grow but never allowing it to take root in a way that would become invasive. Comparatively, Khrushchev’s USSR was one of rupture; trying to be reactive to signs of problems and destabilizing the existing order in the process. Maybe this was intentional opportunism or maybe it was misguided reactivity, I don’t know enough about the details of the history to say. But either way, the evidence seems clear that the USSR got less stable as a result (and ultimately fell), while China went through growing pains in certain ways (and especially, pains from the growth of capital) but with the guiding hand of the CPC, has managed to steer through difficult waters toward overall much better living conditions for the Chinese people.

    To pick out a particular major leader of the CPC in its history, like Mao or Deng, and say “that one was revisionist but the others weren’t” would be to denigrate the CPC itself and decades of history. It would undermine confidence in the party as a whole and its capability as a vanguard for creating the right kind of leaders. Khrushchev was not a “great man” (for good or ill), he didn’t create the conditions under which the USSR was struggling, but his actions do represent the failures of the CPSU to resolve its internal conflicts brought on in part by heavy siege, and find lasting stability. The CPC on the other hand, though it had its conflicts, it has so far managed to resolve them well enough to continue planned and guided transition.

    So in a way, I would say, let’s bring it back to the conditions themselves. The USSR had struggled through a heavy direct war on them. They had come out of it strong militarily, but not strong in fortification. By that I mean, a lot of the power and influence was relatively new, not something created from careful ties built over decades. They were in a position to have a lot of influence over global affairs but without the largely unmarred industrial base that the US had as the growing new head of the white/western empire. They were enmeshed but also in a way that would be hard to extricate themselves from, without being called betrayers of the cause; overextended but invested in staying involved. Used to operating on planning for literal wartime siege, rather than Cold War orchestrated by powers with hundreds of years of experience in having a mask of decorum liberalism over a violent, barbaric face.

    China was much better positioned to largely keep to itself, logistically and culturally. But also faced risk of being isolated and picked off, like other AES states under siege. They lacked the industrial base with which to fight the empire as peers. What did that leave them with? What mechanisms of development, what processes, would enable them to do a thing like lifting 800 million people out of poverty? What would it take to modernize a country of that size?

    Those are the kind of questions I believe we should be thinking about. Purity does not feed people. Correctness does not clothe them. At a certain point, we have to get past the mindset about a binary good/bad view of history and look at what is improving people’s lives and what isn’t, and why. And dialectics helps us see how something can be producing positives at the same time as it is producing negatives. That things are in motion. That a thing can be negating itself in certain ways, while appearing strong or even impenetrable on the surface (a good example of this is western imperialism).

    People can and should aspire for a better world than what we have. They should dream of a world beyond capitalism. We still have to get there though and the people who dedicated their lives to making it happen deserve more respect for their efforts than Khrushchev ever gave to Stalin. They deserve more respect than the average western ultra ever gave to Deng. Not because these people need to be venerated or something, but because if their work doesn’t matter (which is also the work of millions who worked with them) and can be swept away as unimportant with a dismissive hand, then what we are we even fighting for? The inability to recognize the successes of socialism under siege, as well as the challenges that led them to make the decisions they made, is what gets people in a corner trying to somehow do communism without the communism, right where the CIA wants them.

  • pcalau12i@lemmygrad.ml
    link
    fedilink
    English
    arrow-up
    19
    ·
    edit-2
    27 days ago

    Of all of those, Deng was most clearly similar to Bukharin.

    Both Deng and Bukharin agreed with maintaining the socialist state but disagreed with the Stalin Model and wanted to return to a more traditional understanding of Marxian socioeconomic development, as the Stalin Model was largely born out of WW2.

    Khrushchev believed in mostly upholding the Stalin Model economically, only with some minor reforms, but also promoted de-Stalinization socioculturally which was criticized by Deng as being historical nihilist, i.e. it wasn’t merely criticism of Stalin but the complete rejection and essentialization of Stalin as a bad figure of had a negative effect on the morale of the whole socialist project, when your own government is declaring one of your own founders who as extremely evil.

    Deng criticized Gorbachev for not just wanting to move away from the Stalin Model, but also wanting to liberalize the political system. Deng saw this as crazy to weaken the dictatorship of the proletariat prior to undergo massive economic reforms and that it was doomed to fail, and he turned out to be right on that front. Deng took the exact opposite approach and strengthened the dictatorship of the proletariat prior to the reforms, even having the actual Chinese equivalent of Gorbachev placed under house arrest.

    So, a rough overview of the differences in my view:

               | Historical Nihilism | Stalin Model | Dictatorship of the Proletariat
    Deng       |         No          |      No      |              Yes
    Gorbachev  |         Yes         |      No      |              No
    Khrushchev |         Yes         |      Yes     |              Yes* 
    Bukharin   |         No          |      No      |              Yes  
    

    Clearly Deng is more positioned towards Bukharin.

    * I put an asterisk on this one because Khrushchev sometimes started to talk about a “state of the whole people” which some people see that as abandoning the DOTP, although, he did not actually make any significant moves to dismantle the state’s control or the communist party’s authority like Gorbachev did. Gorbachev was unique in that he actively sought out to destroy the Party’s control and to transform the political system to one closer to liberal democracy, and he literally self-identified as a social democrat.

  • LocalAreaMan@lemmy.ml
    link
    fedilink
    arrow-up
    19
    ·
    27 days ago

    Whether Dengism was strategic or a betrayal, Xi is ending it like he’s ended 14 billionaires.

    The sharp rise of sinophobic propaganda in corporate media is further proof.

    • Cowbee [he/they]@lemmygrad.ml
      link
      fedilink
      arrow-up
      36
      ·
      27 days ago

      Xi is not “ending Dengism,” he’s playing his historic role in Reform & Opening Up. Xi’s policies are a continuation of Deng’s, in a China where Reform & Opening Up has worked at rapidly developing the productive forces for several decades now.

      • cfgaussian@lemmygrad.ml
        link
        fedilink
        arrow-up
        19
        ·
        27 days ago

        I think they meant that Xi is ending the debate about whether Deng’s policies were a betrayal or a necessary strategic maneuver. In hindsight it is now clear that the gamble has paid off.

        • Cowbee [he/they]@lemmygrad.ml
          link
          fedilink
          arrow-up
          16
          ·
          27 days ago

          I read it as “Xi is closing the noose on the capitalists in China,” so whether or not Deng truly was a capitalist roader doesn’t matter.