I don’t think it’s quite that bad, it can be a useful word to distinguish people who medically transition from those who don’t, but I do get the ick when cis people use it as an umbrella word, or when trans people use the term as some kind of gold star in some respectability politics game, as if their transness is somehow more valid because they’re a transsexual
there are also some older trans folks who use language like that just because they aren’t “politically aware” or tuned into contemporary queer culture
I think older cis people sometimes use the term for similar reasons.
But yeah, I don’t have strong hopes for the term getting reclaimed, but it would be nice to finally have both an umbrella term (“trans” or “transgender”) that doesn’t just narrowly mean people who both socially & medically transition, and to have a neutral term for people who do happen to socially & medically transition.
Sometimes I just bite the bullet and use the longer phrase “trans person who medically transitioned” - it’s just unwieldy language, but in general audiences it’s probably best to do that to avoid upsetting someone.
I think it would be safest to assume that still; I’m a trans woman who sometimes identifies as a transsexual when I’m trying to be clear in my language or when I’m talking with someone who has shared understanding of what the term means between us.
I don’t think it’s quite that bad, it can be a useful word to distinguish people who medically transition from those who don’t, but I do get the ick when cis people use it as an umbrella word, or when trans people use the term as some kind of gold star in some respectability politics game, as if their transness is somehow more valid because they’re a transsexual
Oh, I was under the impression that it was an old-fashioned term that wasn’t considered appropriate any more.
It was for a while, but there does seem to be an effort to reclaim it recently.
there are also some older trans folks who use language like that just because they aren’t “politically aware” or tuned into contemporary queer culture
I think older cis people sometimes use the term for similar reasons.
But yeah, I don’t have strong hopes for the term getting reclaimed, but it would be nice to finally have both an umbrella term (“trans” or “transgender”) that doesn’t just narrowly mean people who both socially & medically transition, and to have a neutral term for people who do happen to socially & medically transition.
Sometimes I just bite the bullet and use the longer phrase “trans person who medically transitioned” - it’s just unwieldy language, but in general audiences it’s probably best to do that to avoid upsetting someone.
I think it would be safest to assume that still; I’m a trans woman who sometimes identifies as a transsexual when I’m trying to be clear in my language or when I’m talking with someone who has shared understanding of what the term means between us.